I guess I am not a fan of movies that send a much revered franchise into a tailspin. Alien 3 was a trainwreck of a film that in the end was hardly Fincher's project anymore. It relied heavily on the paranoia and claustrophobic feel set up in the original, only more poorly executed. It was too well lit, too predictable and too sterile. I also had a real problem with the offing of the surviving cast of Aliens (Newt, Hicks) offscreen before the story even started. Those were great characters that at least deserved some limited screen time to complete their story arc. If I were Fincher this film wouldn't be listed on my resume. Much like my first job at Mr. Gattis circa 1992.
Honestly - all I remember about Alien Resurrection was Ripley with superhero powers, Winona Ryder and a white Alien with a human skull face. And the general from Commando... I saw it once in the theater and I remember being upset. I guess I need to give it another chance.