The way the Rangers are looking at their starting pitching candidates, it's almost like they are playing a game of Texas Hold 'Em. Tuesday was the day when the cards would determine whether the club went all in on C.J. Wilson or whether it was time to fold and play a different hand.
In Texas Hold 'Em, that turning of three cards is called a "flop."
Wilson's outing was anything but.
Pitching in relief of RHP Neftali Feliz Tuesday, Wilson became the first Rangers pitcher to go four innings this spring. In a word, he was "splendid." At least if the person delivering the description was pitching coach Mike Maddux.
"He was in control the entire time out there, even when he got into a jam, he was in control," Maddux said. "It was a very mature outing. His performance has been at the top of the list, so far."
Wilson needed just 47 pitches to work four innings. He didn't walk a batter. He recorded five strikeouts, all looking. He was able to throw a hard cut fastball into right-handed hitters for called strikes and was also able to freeze them with a sinker that appeared to come back over the plate at the last minute.
He was constantly ahead of hitters, which had been the biggest issue with his three-inning outing against Seattle last week. Wilson was behind eight of 12 Mariners hitters, but got ahead of 11 of the 15 Chicago batters he faced.
And when he did get into trouble, he prevented runners from scoring. He had runners at second and third with no outs in his fourth inning of work, but needed just eight pitches to get three ground ball outs.
"The last two outings, the runners have scored," Wilson said. "I got the hitters, but guys advanced on wild pitches. Today, I pitched out of the jam. I felt like i got ahead of hitters just about every single time."
Maddux said both Feliz, who was outstanding for two innings but ineffective in his third, and Wilson will get at least one more lengthy opportunity on March 22 when the Rangers face San Francisco in Scottsdale. Both are scheduled to throw 80 pitches. The Rangers are off the next day and are expected to make decisions on how to construct the bulk of the pitching staff then.
For both pitchers, simply performing well is not enough to claim a spot in the rotation. The Rangers must also feel comfortable with the construction of the bullpen. Wilson was perhaps the most valuable pitcher in the bullpen last year. On Tuesday, though, Maddux said the current pool of bullpen talent can withstand the loss of Wilson.
"Darren Oliver can fill the role C.J. performed so well in last year," Maddux said. "I like our bullpen. We've got some flexibility out there."
Wilson is scheduled to start the Giants game. In that game, he's likely to face the entire lineup at least twice. That's one thing he's yet to do this spring. On Tuesday, he faced only two hitters twice, right-handed hitting Xavier Nady and left-handed Micah Hoffpauir. Nady provided the lesson Wilson must still master. After striking Nady out with hard stuff inside, Wilson attempted to throw a sinker low and away for the first pitch of the second at-bat. Nady was able to drive the ball into the gap in right center. The lesson: Don't throw something you don't know if a guy can hit when you've already thrown him something he can't.
"There is still a lot left to prove," Wilson said. "This is a phenomenal opportunity and you have to try. There is momentum internally that is driving me to do the absolute best I can."