View Poll Results: Could a College Team beat a Pro Team

Voters
202. You may not vote on this poll
  • Yes

    26 12.87%
  • No

    176 87.13%
+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 50 of 121

Thread: Could a college team beat a professional team?

  1. #1
    asshat Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey has a gigantic e-peen. Vic Mackey's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Posts
    2,552

    Could a college team beat a professional team?

    I wanted the Shag's opinion and reasoning on this.

    I got this from another site and got me thinking about it. I saw the results and was surprised as hell to see how many voted yes. How can anyone can think a college team can beat a professional team in any sport? The shittiest team in the NFL would wipe the floor with a Bama, UT or Florida. And the Nets would destroy Duke or Kentucky.

    I just never saw how anyone could think a college team would have a shot.

  2. #2
    no this is a stupid fucking question and should never be asked again....


    There are over 10,000 NCAA football players and of those 10,000 only about 250 get chosen a year to go to the NFL not all of them make it the ones who do are the best of the best

  3. #3
    asshat texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax aka Old Freak Nasty texassax's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    5,504
    people who think that are fucking morons.

  4. #4
    Cowboys and Texans fan ! tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt aka Old Freak Nasty tx 3 putt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Charlie's Bait Camp
    Posts
    33,691
    not even close

  5. #5
    asshat TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo aka Old Freak Nasty TJ Hooshamazoo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Mac puts the "T" & "A" in Tranny...
    Posts
    25,614
    Quote Originally Posted by Vic Mackey View Post
    I wanted the Shag's opinion and reasoning on this.

    I got this from another site and got me thinking about it. I saw the results and was surprised as hell to see how many voted yes. How can anyone can think a college team can beat a professional team in any sport? The shittiest team in the NFL would wipe the floor with a Bama, UT or Florida. And the Nets would destroy Duke or Kentucky.

    I just never saw how anyone could think a college team would have a shot.
    no fucking way. not even close... and anyone who thinks otherwise is either a fucking moron or European.

  6. #6
    The Son of Chico Dusty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka aka Old Freak Nasty Derka Derka's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Official 2011 Shaggy Fantasy Island Champion
    Posts
    29,856
    Could the 2005 Texas team beat an NFL team if the game was played right now? I dunno, but I think they could compete. Sure, we'd have some guys who aren't NFL material, and the WR's would suck, but we'd have a fairly salty defense, Jamaal Charles, Selvin, and VY in the backfield. Shipley and Quan would probably be our top 2 WR's (I'm counting the entire roster), and the secondary wouldn't be too bad. What would the score be between the Rams and the 2005 Texas team, with all of them playing today?


    I only asked because, the question in the OP is so fucking retarded. (Not saying the OP is retarded, as he said as much)

    Edit: Don't get me wrong, I'm sure we'd lose, but I wanna know how close you all think it could be.

  7. #7
    asshat VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d should starts VoodooChi|d's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Atlanta, GA
    Posts
    5,116
    I picked yes, only because if you pick no, it's an absolute. I don't like absolutes.

  8. #8
    asshat ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY is rapin errbody up in herr. ToY's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    ATX
    Posts
    7,742
    Hell No.

  9. #9
    bunghole dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37 is a rep whore. dpierce37's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    50% ATX-50% GoM
    Posts
    847
    I think anything could happen on Sunday (or saturday). Like voodoo said, it's to absolute to say no.

  10. #10
    Usually Posts GIFs hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785 aka Old Freak Nasty hornfan785's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    9,543
    No..

  11. #11
    asshat GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad is a rep whore. GhostOfTomJoad's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Bloom County
    Posts
    3,294
    fuck this poll gives me flashbacks to hf and onemug, the sooner troll who insisted the '04 sooners--prior to being anally raped by usc--could beat the '04 Oakland Raiders.

    there's no fucking way college kids could be pros in a real game.

  12. #12
    Quote Originally Posted by Vic Mackey View Post
    I wanted the Shag's opinion and reasoning on this.

    I got this from another site and got me thinking about it. I saw the results and was surprised as hell to see how many voted yes. How can anyone can think a college team can beat a professional team in any sport? The shittiest team in the NFL would wipe the floor with a Bama, UT or Florida. And the Nets would destroy Duke or Kentucky.

    I just never saw how anyone could think a college team would have a shot.
    Of course not in Football. But you do say "beat a professional team in any sport" and I disagree with that. A college baseball team could beat a pro baseball team maybe 5% to 10% of the time I would think. On any day luck plays a big role in how a baseball game is going to turn out, and if the MLB team's pitcher implodes or the college teams pitcher has his stuff really working the college team could certainly win.

    Basketball and football it would never happen provided the NFL or NBA team was interested in the proceedings.

  13. #13
    asshat USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC wins the internets! USAOROTC's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    ..-. ..- .-. -.-
    Posts
    3,727

    wait..when did Texags get a orange color scheme?


  14. #14
    asshat oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe is rapin errbody up in herr. oobe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Megadeath, Arkansas
    Posts
    3,206
    Football? No (and yes, it's absolute. as in never)

    Basketball? No

    Baseball? Maybe 1 in 50

    Golf (college player winning a PGA tournament) Sure

    Tennis (same as above) Unlikely, but possible

  15. #15
    bunghole Felix can play the whole course with a 4 iron. Felix can play the whole course with a 4 iron. Felix can play the whole course with a 4 iron.
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    505
    If there was something serious to play for, then I would say a college team in any sport has about a .001% chance of beating a pro team. Again that means it's not an exhibition or some shit like that. A real game with something real on the line.

  16. #16
    i voted YES because a college baseball team could beat a professional low A team. they could possibly even beat a AA team. i think once in every few years a college basketball team could beat a really bad NBA team, if that NBA team relied solely on jump shooters and had a ridiculous off night. a college team could beat a team like the Toros more often than that.

  17. #17
    asshat Drunken Mule WHY IS EVERYBODY PICKING ON ME???11/!3123Lolzfaget Drunken Mule WHY IS EVERYBODY PICKING ON ME???11/!3123Lolzfaget Drunken Mule WHY IS EVERYBODY PICKING ON ME???11/!3123Lolzfaget Drunken Mule WHY IS EVERYBODY PICKING ON ME???11/!3123Lolzfaget Drunken Mule WHY IS EVERYBODY PICKING ON ME???11/!3123Lolzfaget Drunken Mule WHY IS EVERYBODY PICKING ON ME???11/!3123Lolzfaget Drunken Mule's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Under an overpass on I-35
    Posts
    4,864
    Definitely. The game played in the old days between the college all-stars and Super Bowl champs was surprisingly pretty competitive. I'd certainly favor the college team if you were to hypothetically take one of the poorly coached, relatively disorganized NFL teams with shit attitude/morale and put them against a really well-oiled, fired up NCAA team.

  18. #18
    asshat longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan is a rep whore. longhrnfan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    I'm in Miami, Trick.
    Posts
    10,190
    Quote Originally Posted by oobe View Post
    Football? No (and yes, it's absolute. as in never)

    Basketball? No

    Baseball? Maybe 1 in 50

    Golf (college player winning a PGA tournament) Sure

    Tennis (same as above) Unlikely, but possible
    its a dumb question but I agree with oobe

  19. #19
    asshat Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8 is a fucking saint. Longhornmaniac8's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    Austin
    Posts
    1,832
    I'm not going to disagree with football, I think it is highly unlikely bordering on impossible, but basketball? You really don't think Kentucky had enough talent to stick with the Nets this year? I'm not saying they'd win much, but with 5 first rounders, it's gotta make you wonder.

    For baseball, I've gotta think it's possible once in a blue moon. All it would take is a big time pro prospect on the hill, and some luck offensively. Once in a blue moon.

  20. #20
    I agree with oobe, there's a chance in Baseball, especially if you've got an ace who'll be in the pros in a year anyway. Tennis and golf are the most likely scenarios. Other than that though you have to bend the rules: 2005 Texas vs. The Odessa Roughnecks (if thats even football) or 2003 Texas vs. the Austin Torros. Both are "pros" but are kind of cheating the question.

  21. #21
    asshat naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo is rapin errbody up in herr. naked_bongo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    1 mile east of the Disch
    Posts
    6,385
    Hell no. Fuck the off-season. This is the stupidest question ever.

  22. #22
    2005 USC would probably win the Super Bowl

  23. #23
    asshat Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr. Dolemite is rapin errbody up in herr.
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Atlanta, Ga
    Posts
    5,984
    No way. Worst pro team would stomp the best college team.

  24. #24
    asshat mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2 should starts mez2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    showin' naked ass in the great state of Texas
    Posts
    11,128
    as long as we have VY, I like our chances.

  25. #25
    A better question would be, could a college all-American team beat a pro team. I think given time to practice together and develop schemes the answer would be yes, that an all-American team could beat a pro team. But I would still bet on the pro team.

  26. #26
    asshat Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Illegitimum non Carborundum
    Posts
    3,965
    "Do you believe in miracles?"

    If you make the definition as loose as possible, then it's happened (USA hockey v. a not exactly amateur USSR team).

  27. #27
    asshat cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav is a rep whore. cam4mav's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Tucson, AZ
    Posts
    2,425
    Quote Originally Posted by Derka Derka View Post
    Could the 2005 Texas team beat an NFL team if the game was played right now? I dunno, but I think they could compete. Sure, we'd have some guys who aren't NFL material, and the WR's would suck, but we'd have a fairly salty defense, Jamaal Charles, Selvin, and VY in the backfield. Shipley and Quan would probably be our top 2 WR's (I'm counting the entire roster), and the secondary wouldn't be too bad. What would the score be between the Rams and the 2005 Texas team, with all of them playing today?


    I only asked because, the question in the OP is so fucking retarded. (Not saying the OP is retarded, as he said as much)

    Edit: Don't get me wrong, I'm sure we'd lose, but I wanna know how close you all think it could be.

    it would be interesting

    what year (full roster) would have been our most talented team, if they played now?

    whould it be 04 or 03?
    Having Benson, DJ, and Scaife would help alot. and we would keep the OL, DL, and secondary.
    I'd hate to lose Jamaal but to have a more competitive team I think you have to.
    Did Roy leave after 03?

    That would be a fun game to watch. I'm pretty sure that ridiculous Miami team could have beaten some NFL teams a few years ago before they all got hurt.

  28. #28
    Lord Nivek Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Homeless
    Posts
    5,102
    Yes.

    http://collegefootball.rivals.com/co...asp?CID=563257

    he Green Bay Packers of the 1960s are near mythical figures. Even before they won the first two Super Bowls, Vince Lombardi's teams had won three NFL championships. The Packers lost only twice in the postseason under Lombardi in his nine years at the helm.
    They are revered to this day nearly anywhere they go. In Wisconsin they are deities walking the earth.
    But there apparently is one dark day which they choose not to remember: July 23, 1963. That's the day the legendary Packers, the 1962 NFL champions with a record of 13-1, a team that featured no less than 10 future members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame, lost to a bunch of college kids who had practiced together for only three weeks.
    Vince Lombardi was definitely not smiling when his Packers lost to the College All-Stars. The game was the old College Football All-Star game. It pitted a team of NFL draft picks against the defending NFL champion. And on that fateful day in 1963 at Soldier Field in Chicago, the all-stars won 20-17.
    "I'm recently retired, I've done a lot of interviews through the years, and I've decided to cut back on them," former Packers QB Bart Starr said. "I respectfully decline this interview (on the subject of the 1963 all-star game)."
    Fellow Hall of Famers Jim Taylor and Willie Wood said they had no recollection of the game. Perhaps they don't. But in light of how miserable Lombardi made their lives because of it, it's somewhat curious.
    "Maybe they've repressed it," said Pulitzer Prize winner David Maraniss, author of the book When Pride Still Mattered: A Life of Vince Lombardi. "(Lombardi) rode them mercilessly. It was brutal. He kept replaying the film over and over again and chewing out the veterans. Practice was hell all of that week."
    Dave Robinson saw the results of the 1963 all-star game from both sides. The Penn State defender was a part of the college team that beat the Packers, but he also already was signed to play for Green Bay as its first-round pick.
    Robinson went on to play 10 seasons for the Packers. He was a three-time Pro Bowl linebacker.
    "Vince often said that was his most humiliating loss," Robinson said. "He would say, 'All of the great things we did around here, all of the championships, and all they want to write about is the time we lost to the all-stars.' It really bothered Vince."

  29. #29
    WHOSE RESPONSIBLE THIS? AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    The 8th Gate of Hell
    Posts
    860
    I voted yes because it's already happened. Texas beat USC about 5 years ago.

  30. #30
    asshat Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag should starts Montag's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Louisiana
    Posts
    3,354
    Anyone who says yes should have their organs donated and then shot. You're stealing oxygen from the rest of us and really don't need to go on living if you are that damned stupid.

  31. #31
    asshat hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    dirty souf austin
    Posts
    15,629
    i don't even see it in baseball. do the college kids have to use wooden bats? can the pros use aluminum?

  32. #32
    Lord Nivek Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Homeless
    Posts
    5,102
    Quote Originally Posted by Montag View Post
    Anyone who says yes should have their organs donated and then shot. You're stealing oxygen from the rest of us and really don't need to go on living if you are that damned stupid.
    Or maybe the Yes voters know their history a bit better than you. See my post above. Vince Lombardi and his Packers defending champs lost to college all-start draft squad that practiced for 3 weeks.

  33. #33
    asshat longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl should starts longhornsgirl's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    On the internet
    Posts
    9,703
    Nope. On a pro team, all the players are proven on a professional level. On a college team, maybe 1-10 players will make it to the NFL.

  34. #34
    asshat hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn should starts hayden_horn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    dirty souf austin
    Posts
    15,629
    Quote Originally Posted by Nivek View Post
    Or maybe the Yes voters know their history a bit better than you. See my post above. Vince Lombardi and his Packers defending champs lost to college all-start draft squad that practiced for 3 weeks.
    that was 50 years ago. kind of a different sports environment these days.

  35. #35
    I'm tired of this question. Just go ahead and play it. MNC winner vs the team with the worst record in the NFL. The Sunday before the Superbowl. Winners get burnt orange Expeditions.

  36. #36
    asshat smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs is a rep whore. smuggs's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    Sea Rim.
    Posts
    1,201
    Quote Originally Posted by Bullneck View Post
    "Do you believe in miracles?"

    If you make the definition as loose as possible, then it's happened (USA hockey v. a not exactly amateur USSR team).

    I believe in miracles, like the sun and the moon, and even Mars.
    The Milky Way and fucking shooting stars.

  37. #37
    Lord Nivek Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Homeless
    Posts
    5,102
    Quote Originally Posted by hayden_horn View Post
    that was 50 years ago. kind of a different sports environment these days.
    True, but that was a defending champ team that has been together for a little while and had a famous coach vs. a team that has been together for 3 weeks.

  38. #38
    asshat dark54555 grows his own roses dark54555 grows his own roses dark54555 grows his own roses dark54555 grows his own roses dark54555 grows his own roses dark54555 grows his own roses dark54555's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Dallas, TX
    Posts
    1,061
    Quote Originally Posted by oobe View Post
    Football? No (and yes, it's absolute. as in never)

    Basketball? No

    Baseball? Maybe 1 in 50

    Golf (college player winning a PGA tournament) Sure

    Tennis (same as above) Unlikely, but possible
    Football exception - an "all conference" team could probably beat the worst NFL team (Big XII, Big Ten, or SEC...maybe Pac-10).

    Basketball exception - same

    I'm also guessing you could see a 10%-ish win percentage from the top college hockey team over the worst team in the NHL.

  39. #39
    asshat lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint. lazytexasfan is a fucking saint.
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Portland, OR
    Posts
    7,406
    this gets asked every off-season. the answer has been and always will be 'hell no'

  40. #40
    Quote Originally Posted by lazytexasfan View Post
    this gets asked every off-season. the answer has been and always will be 'hell no'
    That's "a likely" answer, not "the" answer. Only one way to find out "the" answer.

  41. #41
    asshat Sii grows his own roses Sii grows his own roses Sii grows his own roses Sii grows his own roses Sii grows his own roses Sii's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Kiss my ass and suck my dick, everyone
    Posts
    8,643
    the best team in college would get ass raped by the worst NFL team

  42. #42
    asshat PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT is a rep whore. PhatAtUT's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    i never listen to bob and dan on 1310 the ticket
    Posts
    3,283
    Quote Originally Posted by FondrenRoad View Post
    I'm tired of this question. Just go ahead and play it. MNC winner vs the team with the worst record in the NFL. The Sunday before the Superbowl. Winners get burnt orange Expeditions.
    if this actually happened it would be the second highest rated thing on tv for the year.

  43. #43
    asshat John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan is rapin errbody up in herr. John Coctostan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Opulence, I has it.
    Posts
    3,790
    Quote Originally Posted by VoodooChi|d View Post
    I picked yes, only because if you pick no, it's an absolute. I don't like absolutes.
    Only a Sith deals in absolutes.

  44. #44
    asshat HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04 aka Old Freak Nasty HornsN04's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Hit him in the fucking head, Kenny.
    Posts
    16,876
    Not only no, but fuck no.

  45. #45
    WHOSE RESPONSIBLE THIS? AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer has a gigantic e-peen. AnotherLawyer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    The 8th Gate of Hell
    Posts
    860
    The question wasn't "would," as in "would the 2001 Miami Hurricanes beat the 2001 Carolina Panthers today." It was "could," as in "could 2001 Miami beat the 2001 Carolina Panthers ever."

    If the answer to "could 2001 Miami beat the 2001 Carolina Panthers" is possibly 1 time out of 1,000 games played, then the answer to "could" is "yes." If the answer to "could 2001 Miami beat the 2001 Carolina Panthers" is possibly 1 time out of 1,000,000 games played, then the answer to "could" is still "yes."

    Answering "no" means that the question was misunderstood. "No" would be more correct than "yes" if the question were "is it likely for a college team to beat a pro team?"

    Answering "no" also means, as others in this thread have point out, that people are disregarding sports history. Teams made up of college players have defeated pro or "pro" teams before.

  46. #46
    asshat Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo aka Old Freak Nasty Quasimofo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Oscar, would you stop admiring me, and change the tire?
    Posts
    4,785
    I voted no, because I took the spirit of the question into mind. But I agree with the people voting yes because of the absolute nature of the question. The '05 Horns football team could beat the shit out of the professional Texas Rangers in a game of football. Or the 09-10 UConn women's basketball team could probably beat the weakest "professional" WNBA team, at least some of the time. But without qualifiers like those, HELL no.

  47. #47
    Lord Nivek Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek has a gigantic e-peen. Nivek's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Homeless
    Posts
    5,102
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/College_All-Star_Game

    Looks like the College All Stars beat or tied the defending Superbowl Champs 11/43 times or ~25%. As time went on, the College All Stars wins became fewer and less common, but the scores indicate they were still somewhat respectable.

    I imagine a revision of this with the worst team in the NFL vs College All-stars/MNC winner the College team would fare much better.
    Last edited by Nivek; 07-30-2010 at 12:30 PM.

  48. #48
    Official Devine Hater Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry should starts Huckleberry's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Sure as hell not in Devine
    Posts
    6,423
    Absolutely could be done in baseball. In fact if a pro team played a top-level college team 100 times I would bet the college team wins at least 8 of the games.

  49. #49
    asshat Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck is a rep whore. Bullneck's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Illegitimum non Carborundum
    Posts
    3,965
    Quote Originally Posted by smuggs View Post
    I believe in miracles, like the sun and the moon, and even Mars.
    The Milky Way and fucking shooting stars.
    hi.




    Personally, I'm 95% sure the pro team will win. Here's my formula:

    Last edited by Bullneck; 07-30-2010 at 12:44 PM.

  50. #50
    I think an interesting one would be if you could combine two of the best college teams that compliment each other. So you wouldn't combine the 05 Horns with USC but with 05 Ohio St. Or the 09 Horns with 09 Alabama.

    A team that combined the O5 Horns and Buckeyes would be pretty darn badass. You'd basically have NFL players at every position. Same with 09 Horns and Crimson Tide.

    They'd beat the worst NFL team at least once in a while.

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Home .. Advertise .. ShaggyShop .. PanchoChat
Football .. Basketball .. Baseball .. Other Sports .. RC Didn't Offer .. Gamboool
Varsity .. Hole in the Wall .. PCL .. Einstein's .. Nasty's .. GM Steakhouse .. NSAA
Bada Bing .. Can you help me with this? .. Shagslist .. Cloak Room .. Classics .. Bellmont